Did Hurricane Harvey hammer home the reality of climate change?
Yes: Harvey shows climate change is real
The real scientists, not the fossil fuel industry shills, have been proven correct.
Rising atmospheric and sea temperatures brought about by the incessant production of environmentally destructive, heat-trapping greenhouse gases have ensured that what were called “500-year storms” are now happening every couple of years.
Hurricane Harvey saw areas of Texas never prone to flooding deluged with up to 50 inches of rain. Interstate highways were turned into raging rivers. The second floors of many homes and apartment buildings were reached by flood waters.
But the epochal flooding of Houston and several other areas of Texas do not represent a one-off event.
As Texas counted the dead and tallied up the billions of dollars in damage caused by Harvey, South Asia saw 1,200 deaths and millions of people made homeless by unusually powerful monsoon rains that left cities in Bangladesh, India, Nepal and Pakistan under water.
In July, unprecedented rains flooded subway stations and turned streets into lakes in Istanbul, one of Europe's most populous cities.
There's no doubt about it: With drastic climate change, the world is experiencing historic storms more often.
Hurricane Katrina did to New Orleans and southern Louisiana in 2005 what Harvey did to Houston and surrounding environs this year — an entire metropolitan area was affected, and the impact will be long-lasting.
Hurricane Rita, which followed Katrina in 2005, served as a stark wake-up call for Houston, which was well-prepared for the wind event but could have never foreseen the floods wrought by Harvey.
Superstorm Sandy in 2012 put New York City on notice that it was not immune to the effects of climate change. Flooded subways and major Internet switching centers in Manhattan were a reality and not fodder for disaster movies.
The Carolinas were continuing to rebuild from 2016’s Hurricane Matthew unprecedented flooding when Harvey struck Texas.
Demands for assistance from such federal entities as the National Flood Insurance Program reached new levels and put new stresses on the already in-debt flood relief fund.
The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration has counted an average of 15 named Atlantic storms each year from 1995 to 2012, an increase from years past. The frequency of the storms was directly attributed to warming oceans resulting from our warming atmosphere.
The simultaneous collapsing of ice formations in Antarctica and the Arctic will have irreversible effects on coastal flooding, sea currents and the abundance of marine life.
The collapse of marine ecosystems is already having disastrous results for species up and down the marine food chain. Eventually, the top of that food chain, humankind, will suffer from oceans devoid of sustaining food resources.
With Miami streets now flooding during non-storm-related tides, a Harvey-like storm striking Miami would leave permanent changes to the shorelines.
President Donald Trump calls climate change a Chinese-manufactured “hoax.”
Perhaps when the president’s Mar-a-Lago estate in Palm Beach, Fla., is inundated by the rising waters of the Atlantic Ocean, he might come to his senses about the realities behind global climate change and understand that his reliance on fake science has put more than his golfing and banquet buddies at risk.
Wayne Madsen is a progressive writer whose columns have appeared in leading newspapers around the world. Readers may write to him 415 Choo Choo Lane, Valrico, FL, 33594.
No: Hurricanes have plagued Texas for a long time
The pundits at elite East Coast media outlets — The New York Times, Washington Post, NBC, CNN and their many satellites — wasted no time in rushing to judgment.
Torrential rains were still flooding a huge area of southeast Texas when they proclaimed Hurricane Harvey a prime example of devastating climate change.
They received standing applause from Al Gore and his legion of federally funded climate alarmists across the country — but they were jarringly wrong.
Hurricane Harvey is a horrible, extreme case of the weather that typically ravages Texas’ Gulf Coast but it has nothing to do with global climate change.
Some in the burgeoning climate disaster industry claim that Harvey was directly caused by man-made climate change, or, at the very least, was made significantly worse by it.
Sen. Bernie Sanders, the independent from Vermont, for example, said, “Is some of the intensity and the magnitude of this related to climate change? I think most scientists believe it is.”
And he”s been joined by countless others making frenzied calls for more government action and saying climate change will make extreme storms more severe.
But for some historical perspective, consider what happened in 1900, when the worst hurricane in American history roared into the port of Galveston, destroying thousands of buildings and killing an estimated 6,000-12,000 people. Harvey, thus far, has accounted for less than 100 fatalities.
University of Washington atmospheric scientist Cliff Mass said climate change did not cause Hurricane Harvey.
“You can’t really pin global warming for something this extreme,” Mass said.
William Happer, an emeritus professor of physics at Princeton University and a former director of energy research of the U.S. Department of Energy, is also among those highly skeptical of global warming as generally explained by mainstream media.
“Climate has been changing since the Earth was formed — some 4.5 billion years ago,” he wrote in an op-ed earlier this year. “Climate changes on every time scale —whether decades, centuries or millennia. The climate of Greenland was warm enough for farming around the year 1100 A.D., but by 1500, the Little Ice Age drove Norse settlers out. There is no opportunity for a hoax, since climate change is so well documented by historical and geophysical records.”
Debate between skeptical academics like Happer and his undoubting colleagues doing research with federal grants will likely continue ad infinitum.
In the meantime, tens of thousands of Texans are homeless, hungry and quite possibly shell-shocked.
A native of El Paso, Texas, Whitt Flora is an independent journalist who covered the White House for The Columbus Dispatch and was chief congressional correspondent for Aviation Week & Space Technology magazine. Readers may write him at 319 Shagbark Road, Middle River, Md., 21220.
This story was originally published September 7, 2017 at 3:35 PM with the headline "Did Hurricane Harvey hammer home the reality of climate change?."