OLYMPIA -- The Washington Supreme Court on Thursday dismissed a lawsuit filed by Sen. Lisa Brown, D-Spokane, who sought to invalidate a requirement that tax bills considered by the Legislature must pass by a two-thirds supermajority.
Voters approved the requirement by passing Initiative 960 in 2007.
That initiative was a reaffirmation of Initiative 601, passed in 1993, which required that any act by the Legislature that raised or altered taxes had to be approved by a two-thirds majority.
Initiative 601 was reaffirmed by the Legislature several times over the next eight years, but suspended for the 2001-03 biennium when the state faced a revenue shortfall, and again from 2005-07.
The law was reinstated in 2006, and then voters passed the Tim Eyman-sponsored Initiative 960 in 2007.
In 2008, lawmakers tried to reinstate a liquor surcharge but the bill didn't win a supermajority, passing by only a 25-21 margin.
Brown questioned whether the requirement violated the state constitution, but Lt. Gov. Brad Owen, who presides over the Senate, ruled the supermajority was needed. Brown then filed the suit.
The court Thursday declined to interfere in Owen's decision as president of the Senate and dismissed the case.
Senate Republican Leader Mike Hewitt of Walla Walla praised the decision as a "win for the people of Washington."
"It's great news, especially as we're hearing talk of new taxes to fill the state's budget hole, that the public will be protected from the Legislature passing huge tax hikes by a simple majority vote," Hewitt said. "My colleagues and I will continue to advocate for balancing the state's budget without tax increases."
Brown said the decision wouldn't affect any actions lawmakers take during the current legislative session as they wrestle with a projected $8.3 billion revenue shortfall for the remainder of this biennium and for 2009-11.
She said majority Democrats already have vowed that if any tax increases are proposed, they'll be put on the ballot for voters to decide rather than being approved by the Legislature.
Similar stories:
Gregoire's oil fee lacks traction in Legislature
Gregoire's oil fee lacks traction in Legislature
Gov. Chris Gregoire's plan to get transportation revenue through a fee on oil is unlikely to pass the Legislature.
TOLL: Eyman’s anti-tolling initiative too close to call
TOLL: Eyman’s anti-tolling initiative too close to call
OLYMPIA — A Tim Eyman initiative that would disrupt Washington's use of tolling and prohibit light rail from crossing the Interstate 90 bridge across Lake Washington was narrowly trailing in election returns Tuesday night.
Less than 51 percent of voters were opposing Initiative 1125 in early results tallied from 1.1 million votes. It was the only statewide ballot measure that was at risk of losing, sullied by broad opposition to the measure — from Democratic Gov. Chris Gregoire to Republican gubernatorial candidate Rob McKenna.
Eyman said that no matter the final tally, the campaign had made tolls a radioactive issue for lawmakers.
State shouldn't count on voter support for taxes
State shouldn't count on voter support for taxes
We agree with Gov. Chris Gregoire on at least one thing -- cuts in state spending she proposed last week are unacceptable.
"I have seen the ramifications of the cuts," Gregoire told reporters at a news conference in Olympia. "I can't live with it."
But her call for a statewide referendum on a temporary half-cent sales tax increase is premature. The last thing Washington taxpayers need at this stage is to let the Legislature off the hook by dangling some false hope of new revenues.
State shouldn't count on voter support for taxes
State shouldn't count on voter support for taxes
We agree with Gov. Chris Gregoire on at least one thing -- cuts in state spending she proposed last week are unacceptable.
"I have seen the ramifications of the cuts," Gregoire told reporters at a news conference in Olympia. "I can't live with it."
But her call for a statewide referendum on a temporary half-cent sales tax increase is premature. The last thing Washington taxpayers need at this stage is to let the Legislature off the hook by dangling some false hope of new revenues.
In Mass. Senate race, GOP's Brown embracing Obama
In Mass. Senate race, GOP's Brown embracing Obama
During the 2010 special election to fill the seat left vacant by the death of U.S. Sen. Edward Kennedy, then-candidate Scott Brown vowed to be the "41st" vote against President Barack Obama's sweeping health care overhaul.
Print
Email Story
